Convenience: Many residents appreciate the neighborhood's central location and easy access to major roads and highways, making it easy to get around Louisville and the surrounding areas. There are also several shopping centers, restaurants, and other amenities within walking distance, which adds to the neighborhood's convenience.

Safety: Many residents feel that St. Matthews is a safe place to live. The neighborhood has a lower crime rate than many other areas of Louisville, and residents note that they feel comfortable walking around the neighborhood at night.

Schools: St. Matthews is home to several high-performing public and private schools, which is a draw for families with children. The quality of the schools is often cited as one of the reasons why people choose to live in the neighborhood.